The Fellowship / Fellows / schiessle / blog / Is a free DRM better than a non-free DRM?

Is a free DRM better than a non-free DRM?

On the first Open Mind Commons (OMC) Workshop Sun Microsystems released two draft specifications for Digital Restrictions Management (DRM): DReaM-CAS (Conditional Access System) and DReaM-MMI (Mother May I) and a free (as in freedom) prototype implementation of the DReaM-CAS conditional access system.

So far it isn't anything special that the industry works on DRM systems. Maybe it's new that they try to create a DRM standard based on Free Software, but i don't consider it as an advantage to use Free Software to restrict users freedom.

For me the news become interesting when i read a comment by Lawrence Lessig:

"In a world where DRM has become ubiquitous, we need to ensure that the ecology for creativity is bolstered, not stifled, by technology. We applaud Sun's efforts to rally the community around the development of open-source, royalty-free DRM standards that support "fair use" and that don't block the development of Creative Commons ideals."
I was really astonished, this sounds like Lawrence Lessig has given up his fight against DRM and for a "Free Culture" and has resigned to the fact that our future will be an opaque culture full of restrictions. It is particularly interesting because Lawrence Lessing is on the board of directors of the FSF and the EFF which has already published a press release against Suns Open Mind Commons DRM.
Verbatim copying and distribution of this entire article are permitted worldwide, without royalty, in any medium, provided this notice is preserved.

Comments

Further thoughts

Hi Bjoern! :)



I was thinking about the subject more, and eventually wrote a blog post.

Re: The problem of finding a balance

Shane, thanks for posting a reply. I wouldn't consider digital copies as a problem but as a great opportunity for society as a whole. But i have some questions: Does authors wrote books before the invention of the printing press? Does artists create great music before the invention of records?

I think both answers are "Yes", so the possibility to earn a lot of money by selling records is definitely a nice option but not the (only) reason to create all this great works. Lawrence Lessig has mentioned in his free culture talk 2002 that five times the number of CDs sold were traded on the Net for free which causes a drop in sales of five percent. Let's be naive and assume that the Internet is responsible for the complete 5%. Is this in any relation? Our culture has been spread five times as much and only causes a loss of 5% for one single industry. Don't forget all the other industries which may have a win, probably much higher than 5%, through this new technology.
As i have written here i think artists today have a lot of options to earn money without restricting the users.

I agree, we need to find a balance. But for me the balance must come from a clever system of industrial and commercial regulations. Trying to regulate and control what private persons do non-commercially will never create a balance but a police state where people will lose their freedom.
Beside the social harm this would destroy or at least harm a whole bunch of industries just to increase the profit of one single industry only as large as the corrugated paper industry (to quote Lawrence Lessig). Just ask yourself why people buy computers, large harddrives, CD/DVD writers, CD-R's, DVD-R's, stand-alone DVD players/recorders, etc.

The problem of finding a balance

Not everyone wants to produce work for free (as in beer). The problem in the digital arena is that once people have one copy of something, they can produce unlimited copies to give to others. For writers, artists and other creative fields this is a problem. The creative process has a real cost in terms of resources (time, energy), but the new distribution networks have eroded the potential for recouping that investment. This is a substantial point in favour of DRM. As I said before, I believe we're going to need to introduce some way to limit how copyrighted information is spread in the digital realm. The problem is to find an implimentation that does not erode user rights in an unfair manner.

Log in or join the Fellowship to post comments.


Trackbacks


Right menu

Fellow Events

<< December 2008 >>
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30 31 
Selected Day Today


FSFE Card


DRM.info
© FSFE